Have You Ever Been to a Hog Killin’? – Part 1: Raising Hogs

“Have you ever been to a hog killin’?” Joel Salatin posed this question to his readers in his book entitled Folks, This Ain’t Normal – A Farmer’s Advice for Happier Hens, Healthier People, and a Better World. I remember reading it and shifting uncomfortably in my chair as he described the process:

Crack! The first .22 caliber rifle shot indicates the start of the day. The oldest and wisest man sticks the hog in the carotid artery to commence the bleeding…

Although I fundamentally understood where meat came from, his description made a previously abstract concept real for me. It wasn’t the killing that bothered me. It was the recognition of how much knowledge, experience, and independence we have lost by relying on factory farmed meat. After reading Joel’s summary, I knew with certainty that I would not be capable of safely butchering a hog. As that idea sank in, I recognized the depth of my “food insecurity.”

Seeking Food Security at Local Farms

When Joel continued on to detail scalding and scraping the pig carcass, the womenfolk directing where the “pancreas, lungs (lights), liver, and kidneys go,” and the preparation that takes place while cuts are made, I determined that these were things I needed to know. So, I headed out to the pasture-raised pig farms in my area to get involved in the process. Although I learned a lot about raising pigs, none of those farmers were doing their own butchering. They were sending live pigs to USDA-approved facilities for processing and inspection so they could legally sell their meat to the public. I am sure those capable farmers could have butchered a pig in a bind, but none of them actually had.

Discovering that the very people who raised my pork answered “no” to Joel’s question reinforced my concerns. I couldn’t help but wonder what would happen if the meat processors went on strike. Or what if there was an extended power outage and we had to do things the old-fashioned way? Would we be able to figure it out and did we even have the tools to do it? At the time, I had to assuage my worries with more canned goods in my basement. But the desire to know how to slaughter a hog at home remained. Two years later, after we started our own small farm in North Carolina, we were finally able to organize our own hog killin’.

Raising Our Own Pigs

In our rural neck of the woods, you can buy ready-to-butcher pigs. However, since we are building our homesteading skills, we opted to raise our own. We found a breeder in our county and put a deposit on four Yorkshire “weaners” (usually 2-5 week old pigs). We asked for females because based on our experience with other livestock, females have been easiest to raise (castrated males are noted for docility as well). We needed extra time to get ready for pigs, so the breeder agreed to keep our pigs with their mama until 8 weeks of age. We learned later that the breeder did us a favor in more ways than one because the longer pigs nurse, the faster they grow and they fewer behavioral and health problems they have.

In mid-April we picked up our four power-packed bundles of cat-sized blubber. They squealed bloody murder as we tried to catch them and it took near Herculean effort to wrestle them into the hatchback of my Honda Fit (a.k.a. my farm truck). Luckily, other than the stench of pig poop, the rest of the ride home was uneventful. In retrospect, picking up the pigs turned out to be the hardest part of raising them.


Our pig shelter

Creating Habitat for Our Pigs

Initially, the girls spent most of their time hiding under loose straw in their three-sided shelter. We constructed it with salvaged hardwood pallets, plywood, sheet metal, 2x4s, and fixed it in place on our hillside using 4x4s set in concrete. Pigs are notoriously hard on their shelters, so building a solid structure was important. However, having just been separated from their mother and relocated to a strange place, these pigs were so timid and quiet at first that I nudged them occasionally to make sure they were still alive. A few days later, they began to wait at their food bowls as I approached. Shortly after that, they started circling me like sharks whenever I stepped in their pen to give them breakfast and dinner. In the heat of the day, they napped under outcroppings of trees. Mornings and late afternoons they snouted up roots, loosened rocks, and tilled the soil. They created new wallows when it rained. This is pretty much how they spent their time until their final fated day.

We started the girls off inside an electric fence within a fixed fence because we had heard horror stories of weaners burrowing under wire and wreaking havoc or disappearing. Our pigs tore up the entire interior perimeter of the electric fence, but never tried to escape. To make sure they were “wire-trained,” I would set their food down outside the fence and walk away. The girls complained loudly with sorrowful wailing, but never crossed the polywire strands. Soon, I started to move them around our property using temporary fencing. I opted for $2 plastic posts placed 10 – 15 feet apart with polywire lines running at about 6″ and 14″ high. The posts had built-in slots to hold the electric wire, but after a few slots broke off, I started wrapping the wire around the posts for added stability. I used a portable solar fence charger on a grounding stake, that gave such a small electric jolt I still can’t believe it deterred the pigs. I lured the pigs to new paddocks with food buckets. Then I watched in wonder as they demolished large patches of brier and pushed fallen limbs out from under the best shady spots to make themselves at home.

During one heavy rain, a sow slid through the fence and buried part of the polywire in the mud. This stopped the flow of current through the fence. The other girls, sensing the change, tentatively stepped over the fence. Thanks to the wet soil, they cleared quite a bit of new ground before we coaxed them back inside their fence using a food bucket. After that I was careful not to run the fence across overly-steep areas. When I delivered food, I also touched the fence to make sure it was “live.” If the current felt weak, I walked the fence line and freed the wire from debris the girls had pushed against it. Overall, as long as the pigs had shade, food, water, land to work, and a live-wire identifying boundaries, they seemed content to stay put.

Most of the pigs’ drinking water came from passive rain collection. We attached gutters and a rain barrel to their shelter and placed the barrel inside their pen to make filling water buckets easy. When the girls started working as a team to tip the barrel and create wallows, we moved the barrel outside the polywire. That stopped the tipping problem, but the barrel was too small to last us through dry periods. We ended up hauling buckets of water to the pigs on some of the hottest days. Next year, we’ll use a bigger cistern.

How Much Water Does it Take to Raise Pigs?

On the subject of water, there is a lot of concern about the “water footprint” in meat. As clean drinking water is becoming less accessible around the planet, appropriate water use is a very important topic. But this is an area where there is a lot of misunderstanding and misuse of data to support particular views. The Water Footprint Network has a great tool to give you a sense of the amount of water used in agricultural items. According to their data, it takes 5,990 liters of water (global average) to make a kilo of pork. Beef takes about 15,400 liters for a kilo. Cabbage, by contrast, is only about 230 liters of water per kilo. That makes cabbage the clear winner in the water footprint race. Right?

Yes, but not by as much as you might think. A pound of cabbage has about 118 calories. A pound of beef has about 1137 calories. In terms of human energy, you need to eat 9.6 times more cabbage than beef to make a fair comparison. At that rate, cabbage will run you 2208 liters of water. It’s still a “win” for cabbage, but realistically eating 9.6 pounds of cabbage or similar amounts of any other vegetable would be hard. Therefore, most people include calorie-dense foods in their diet. Vegetarians eat dairy. Vegans eat nuts. Pork stacks up competitively with those alternatives. On a per calorie basis, pork beats eggs, chicken, and nuts, and runs a close race with dairy products and fruit.

On our homestead, our pigs drank about 4 gallons of rain water per pound of meat produced. This is more than in an industrial environment because we gave them extra water to wet their wallows. We used about 1/4 gallon per pound for cleaning and processing, which is less than industrial use. We bought some bagged feed which definitely left a wet footprint. But we sourced most of their food from local farms that required minimal irrigation since we get good rainfall here. About 30% of their diet came from our unirrigated garden. We probably beat the average water footprint for pork, but we’ll do even better when our pasture is developed.

Feeding Our Pigs

Pigs can feed themselves totally on pasture… if there’s enough food growing in it. Our new paddocks were too full of inedible rhododendrons and mountain laurel, so supplemental feed was necessary. But the work the pigs did to clear the land and fertilize it with poop will reduce and eventually eliminate feed costs over the next few years. As the pigs tilled, I followed behind them to clear rocks and gather stumps, branches, and roots to use later in small hugel-swales. Pigs don’t sweat, so they need wallows (mud baths) to stay cool. So, I only moved the girls to new paddocks when there was a good chance of rain so they could make wallows without me hauling the water. In the vacated pasture, I raked out pig patties and over-seeded with buckwheat, mustard, hairy vetch, and winter wheat to prevent soil erosion and compaction. The rain also watered the seeds in before the birds could eat them all.

Come spring, I’ll scythe down these cover crops and seed the area with fast growing pig favorites – beets, turnips, beans, radishes, and greens of all kinds. When the plants hit maturity, I’ll move our next round of pigs in and let them feed themselves. When I move the pigs out of each paddock next time, I plan to convert sections of pasture to perennials like comfrey, berries, and black locust and crab apple trees for coppicing to evolve the system to be self-sustaining. I’ll also add more paddocks so I can move the pigs more frequently to reduce disturbance to the soil.

This time we spent about $400 per pig on feed over a 7 month period. The girls hit “market weight” (225-250 lbs) in late August, but we had to wait for cool weather to slaughter. We ended up feeding them 2 1/2 months longer than necessary. They were over 300 pounds by November, even though we reduced feed to limit weight gain. In addition to feed the pigs ate garden scraps and long-producing greens like kale, chard, and Malabar spinach. They ate tulip poplar, red sumac, and black locust leaves like candy. Friends gave us spent beer grains which we mixed with feed at a rate of 30%. We gave them our leftovers (except pork which went to the chickens). Towards the end, we gave them deer apples since those were a cheap pig favorite.

Our feed costs per pound of finished meat product came to $2.05. Including the price of the pigs it was $2.50 per pound. These values don’t include our time or our set-up costs. Pig care took 20-40 minutes per day depending on how much water had to be hauled. Hog killin’ and meat product making took several days and lots of helping hands. Pasture creation is ongoing and will add up to weeks of time when finished. Running electric wire took a few hours per paddock, mostly due to time spent clearing brush. There was also time spent on feed pick-up, but we combined that with other activities for efficiency.

The Cost of Homegrown Pork

With a little ingenuity, you can eventually raise your own pigs at a lower cost than buying pork from the store. For budgeting purposes, a safe estimate on feed is 5 pounds of feed for one pound of meat. If you buy feed in 50-pound bags, just drop the zero on your target pig weight to come up with your number of bags, e.g. a 250-pound pig takes 25 bags of feed, at $16 a bag, that’s $400. Most of the feed expense will occur in the last two months of the pig’s life. You can buy weaner pigs for $45, but $85-$100 seems more typical for quality meat breeds. A 250-pound pig will get you roughly 150 pounds of meat products (more if you use organs, scrape the head, and pick bones clean). In our area, we can buy pork for an average cost of $6 per pound (more for loin, bacon, cured ham, less for breakfast sausage, lard, roasts). So, the market value of 150 pounds of meat for us is about $900.

If you only had to buy feed and weren’t worried about assigning a value to your time, you could save about $400 per pig. But if you are starting from scratch, you may not come out ahead your first year. Infrastructure costs for keeping and butchering pigs vary greatly depending on personal preferences. We spent about $700 on fencing and shelter, but others have found ways to do it for pennies on the pound. As you are making your choices, you may want to plan for: 1) enough fencing to let the pigs do some free-ranging, 2) shelter, 3) water storage and delivery method, 4) feed, 5) pig purchase price, 6) tools for home butchering or costs for professional butchering, 7) supplies/equipment for making sausage, meat cures, and packaging products, and 8) a place to store your 150+ pounds of pork per pig (e.g. freezer, larder, curing shed). Then to be safe, add 15% for the stuff you didn’t realize you needed! I also recommend that you don’t count your pork pounds before they are consumed. If you are hanging a ham, you’ll lose 40% of the starting weight in the curing process and you have to wait 8 months or longer for full flavor.

Final Thoughts on Raising Pigs

Finally, pigs are definitely social creatures, so budget for at least two pigs. If you don’t need that much meat, consider co-raising pigs with friends or neighbors. There are a lot of regulations about selling packaged meats after slaughter, but there is often more latitude if you co-raise animals and butcher together. Make sure you know your local and state ordinances. Your agricultural extension agent can usually point you in the right direction.


Pigs in pasture

Fencing, watering, feeding, and budgeting for pigs is the easy part. Saying goodbye is hard. Despite my efforts at keeping a “professional distance,” I still fell in love with those girls. I couldn’t help but admire the single-mindedness with which they worked the pasture, their pure joy over fresh vegetables, or the hilarity of four giant beasts curled up together under some measly pine trees at noon. But I knew what was coming. As we got closer to the kill date I hovered over our pigs while they ate to acclimate them to my prolonged proximity. I repeatedly touched the “stun spot” (found by making an X between their eyes and ears) where we would eventually shoot them with a .22. I also practiced lining them up and spacing them out as I had seen in the “To Kill a Pig Nicely” video from Farmstead Meatsmith. The pigs even stood still as I measured them from shoulder to tail, and around their girth, to estimate their weight for planning purposes. It sounds so calculating in retrospect. But in fact, my actions evolved naturally because I wanted the events that followed to be as stress-free as possible, for all of us.

My girls were well over 300 pounds and still growing. Their ability to decimate pasture increased exponentially with each pound of flesh. As our first frosts came and went, our garden scraps dwindled, and our feed costs increased. The time had come to do what we set out to do at the start of this adventure.

In Joel’s description, the conversion from carcass to ready-to-eat meat occurs alongside the killing and cutting. Organs are boiled, hams rubbed down and hung in the curing house, and trimmings are converted into sausage along the way. But Joel’s hog killin’ was a regular event, attended by people who knew their roles. We were novices, making this up as we went along. To keep it manageable, we broke the process into a two-day event:

Day 1 – Hog Killin’: kill, scald, de-hair, primal cut, and chill.

Day 2 – Hog Cookin’: make delicious stuff.

If you are undaunted by what you’ve read so far, then hold tight for two more posts on Hog Killin’ and Hog Cookin’.

This article is part 1 of a 3 part series called “Have You Ever Been to a Hog Killin’?” about raising, harvesting, and cooking pigs. You can read the rest of the series here:

Part 1: Raising Hogs
Part 2: Hog Killin’
Part 3: Hog Cookin’


Subscribe to TGN's bi-weekly newsletter

The Grow Network is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate program designed to provide a means for our team to earn fees for recommending our favorite products! We may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you, should you purchase an item after clicking one of our links. Thanks for supporting TGN!


Tasha Greer is a regular contributor to The Grow Network and has cowritten several e-books with Marjory Wildcraft. You can follow her ABCs of Homesteading Series on the Mother Earth News homesteading blog; read her reLuxe renderings; or find her at the Surry County, North Carolina, seasonal farmers’ markets, where she sells hand-processed duck, plants, herbs, and other edibles raised at the reLuxe Ranch.

(Visited 88 times, 1 visits today)
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Categorised in: , , , , ,

This post was written by Tasha Greer


  • Dave says:

    Great article Tasha. If you didn’t grow up doing it it sure is a different feeling as you get ready to kill and butcher your own food! Certainly an experience I feel everyone should have at some point in their lives. I am preparing to raise pigs for the first time next year and will be interested in hearing the rest of your story!

  • Jordan says:

    Great article! Been thinking about raising hogs come spring. Can’t wait for the rest of the articles.

  • mj says:

    My impression of your relationship with these intelligent “girls” is that they were daily seen as animated stuffed animals on your worksite, doing interesting things so far…. we ran into some problem with our herdshare when the operator for the group would choose some ‘genetic’ goal and cull what mamas didn’t fit… while grieving over the idea that some were ‘good cows’ who produced well, were gentle and easy to work with, even having *named* them when he got them…..

    I doubt you named your ‘girls’ though it would seem too awkward to relay ideas with your co-working family unless you had identities assigned…

    Maybe if the ‘products’ were just packages so no identities were lingering…

    I wish someone would do a comparison with farmed lives versus living in the dangerous, unsheltered free wildness….. the daily terror-level, the availability of food and places satisfactory but the delights of performance and luck… versus shortened but comfortable farm life,

    our cats (we do a cat rescue and feed them pork and chicken and egg) favor indoors and pet-rules BUT they are not really from this environment (for nearly all of them) and even those with bodily-gifts appropriate to this climate are deprived of some well-being by human society’s use of resources……

    so yeah we are worried about disruptions of our managing lives and how we could care for our rescuees for extended periods, like a year or two maybe… so far that leaves eggs and possibly mealworm-culturing (just freeze them when grown enough)….

    we’re not vegan and see that nature makes some creatures carnivores… i just wish the slaughter process could be preceded by a mild electrical current to shut down consciousness (ala Dr Robert O Becker)… complicated calculation of priorities and we appreciate your exploring what optimums we have at this point….. ttyl

    1. Jean says:

      Judging from the animals’ reaction to electric fences, “a mild electrical current to shut down consciousness” would be very cruel. A quick shot behind the ear with a gun drops the animal without it even knowing there is anything happening. The x between the eyes and ears does not work on large animals such as bison. They just shake their heads as the shell bounces off and get a bit peeved.

  • Thanks for the informative article, Tasha. We’re in our first 8 months of pig raising here with our 5 American Guinea Hogs. I’m always looking for stories about how other homesteaders are handling their gardens and livestock. I’ll be heading to your website as soon as this is posted.
    Merry Christmas!
    Stony Creek Permaculture Farm

    1. Hey Joe,

      I went to your site too. You’ve got some awesome stuff going on. I really appreciated your article on your garden this year – and the realities that even great gardeners have some failures. Made me feel better about my ongoing battle with cabbage moths!

      Best to you!


      1. Joe says:

        Thanks Tasha, but all of the articles on the website are by my lovely wife, Irida. She is the head gardener on our homestead. I built the website and do more of the work on the animal side, raising rabbits, chickens, ducks and American Guinea Hogs.
        As for bees, I plan to start with a hive this spring. I’m going with the Top Bar Hive as it seems more natural and gentle on the bees. I did note that your lone surviving hive was top bar. I got the impression that the ones that failed were Langstroth, although I don’t believe that was actually stated.
        Merry Christmas!

        1. Dave says:

          Hi Joe,
          Curious about the American Guinea Hogs you are raising. How big were they when you butchered them? How long did it take to harvest? I am doing my first batch of pigs this spring at our farm and we are trying to figure out what breed to go with. Just curious on the Am Guinea hog, I have heard mixed things.

  • FrankG says:

    Excellent article! I was raised on a farm in the Appalachians where we butchered cows and pigs for our own use. Many of the neighbors would gather at various farms over the course of a couple of weeks to help in the efforts. Each neighbor seemed to have a specialty he or she had perfected over the years. All working together made for a great day, stopping for an incredible lunch.

  • Nova says:

    When my children were in 4H, we raised 3-4 hogs each year for them to show and sell, always with an extra to eat. Ours were raised on concrete, which is water-intensive, but very clean. We didn’t have the option to use pasture like this article describes, but I plan to raise more next year, and I’d like to try that technique; it has lots benefits. One tip I received from our butcher, is that market weight is not the best weight for great meat. At 225 lbs. the hog has minimal bacon (and I’m guessing minimal fat); if they’re allowed to grow to around 260 or more, the cuts of meat are better and you’ll have plenty of bacon….and farm-raised bacon is more like fat ham slices than the pale strips of fat that is labeled as bacon in the grocery store.

    1. Thanks for the bacon tip! I love farm bacon. Every slice is different. They don’t shrink as much or curl up. I read somewhere that grocery store bacon is pressed into blocks so that it can be uniformly sliced using a machine that makes hundreds to thousands of slices per minute. I suspect that’s why they lose form when you put them in a pan.

      Good luck raising pigs in pasture. Let us know how it goes!


  • Lucy Gabzdyl says:

    Very informative article, thank you. As a conscious omnivore I would like to raise and butcher my own animals in the future to ensure that they have a humane death. I had read before that when you butcher an animal you have raised you really appreciate each mouthful – and gratitude is what it is all about.

  • Phog says:

    Check out Mark Baker’s new breed of Mangalista pigs. The meat is the best pork in the world. Where your average pigs sells at the market for say, $400 to $500……….these Mangalistas can go for $1500 to $2500 depending on what gourmet chef you sell them to…..and if you set up your own processing room with approved stainless steel design and all……you can sell your own processed meats at local health food stores in your region and make even more than that. Amazing flavor….the belly fat is nearly 3 times as thick as normal breeds of pigs…… so there ya go. Research it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *